Coil Framing Nailer vs Stick Nailer: Which One to Choose?

A framing nailer is used in large carpentry projects such as framing house, building a deck or constructing a new room, fence building etc.

In these projects, using a heavy-duty framing nailer is useful because it can hold more nails than other nail guns like finishing or brad nailer.

Though it is the main task of a framing nailer according to the design and features, there are some differences in framing nailer.

According to the nails holding capacity, framing nailer has two types.

  1. Coil framing nailgun
  2. Stick framing nailer

In a Hurry? Check Our Top Picks

Products
Top Coil Nailer
BOSTITCH Coil Roofing Nailer, 1-3/4-Inch to 1-3/4-Inch (RN46)
Top Stick Nailer
BOSTITCH Framing Nailer, Round Head, 1-1/2-Inch to 3-1/2-Inch (F21PL)
Name
BOSTITCH RN46 Nailer
Bostitch F21PL Nailer
Type
Coil
Stick Nailer
Magazine Capacity
300 Nails
60 plastic collated 21-degree framing nails
Weight
5.8 Pounds
10.6 Pounds
Warranty
1 Year
1 Year
Prime Status
Top Coil Nailer
Products
BOSTITCH Coil Roofing Nailer, 1-3/4-Inch to 1-3/4-Inch (RN46)
Name
BOSTITCH RN46 Nailer
Type
Coil
Magazine Capacity
300 Nails
Weight
5.8 Pounds
Warranty
1 Year
Prime Status
Top Stick Nailer
Products
BOSTITCH Framing Nailer, Round Head, 1-1/2-Inch to 3-1/2-Inch (F21PL)
Name
Bostitch F21PL Nailer
Type
Stick Nailer
Magazine Capacity
60 plastic collated 21-degree framing nails
Weight
10.6 Pounds
Warranty
1 Year
Prime Status

Coil Framing Nailer

It’s a good question that what a coil framing nailer is! The definition is right in the name as ‘coil’. Coil means something which is arranged in a series of circles.

So, it can be said that ‘something’ in a framing nailer is arranged in a series of circles. And that ‘something’ is the ‘ails’.

The nails in the framing nailer are gathered into a sequence and twisted like a coil and for this reason, it’s called as coil framing nailer.

Best Coil Framing Nailer

Bestseller No. 1
Metabo HPT NV90AGS Pneumatic Coil Framing Nailer, 1-3/4-Inch up to 3-1/2-Inch Wire Collated Coil Framing Nails, Tool-less Depth Adjustment, Convenient Side Load, Tilt Bottom Magazine, 5-Year Warranty
  • Same tools. New name. Hitachi power tools has renamed to Metabo HPT
  • New head guard design allows for quicker disassembly during tool maintenance
  • Lightweight at 7. 7 lbs. and well-balanced for ease of maneuverability and less user fatigue
  • Accepts 1-3/4" Up to 3-1/2" Wire Collated coil framing nails
  • Convenient side load, tilt bottom MAGAZINE allows for quick and easy fastener replenishment
BOSTITCH N89C-1 Coil Framing Nailer
  • Pneumatic coil framing nailer with an adjustable exhaust
  • Patented push-button adjustable depth guide sets nails to desired depths quickly and easily
  • Lightweight magnesium design; aggressive wear guards to protect the tool from damage on abrasive surfaces
  • Magazine holds up to 300 nails
  • 12-1/4 inches long, 14 inches high; weighs 8.1 pounds; 7-year limited warranty

Stick Framing Nailgun

A stick framing nailer is a nailing kit where the nails are holding in a stick like a magazine. Usually, in this kind of nailer, nails are loaded as a strip which makes it less heavy than coil framing nailer.

Best Stick Framing Nailgun

SaleBestseller No. 1
Metabo HPT NR90AES1 21 Degree Pneumatic Framing Nailer, The Preferred Pro Brand of Pneumatic Nailers, Lightweight and Well-balanced, Easy Depth Adjustment, Accepts 2" to 3-1/2" Collated Framing Nails
  • Same tools. New name. Hitachi Power Tools has renamed to Metabo HPT
  • The Preferred Pro Brand of Pneumatic Nailers. *Based on the 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018 & 2019 Product Brand Surveys in Builder & Developer Magazine
  • Fasteners: Accepts 2" up to 3-1/2" plastic collated framing nails
  • Lightweight: At only 7.5 lbs and well-balanced allowing for ease of maneuverability and less user fatigue
  • Applications: Great for flooring and framing, truss build-up, window build-up, sub flooring, roof decking, wall sheathing and housing construction.
Sale
BOSTITCH N80SB-1 Framing Stick Nailer
  • Lightweight
  • Adjustable depth control
  • Multidirectional exhaust
  • Accurate nail placement

Coil vs Stick Framing Nailer: 4 Points Comparison

The functions of the coil and stick framing nailer are same. Both nailers are used to do heavy duty housebuilding works such as framing new house, decks, fence building and framing the structure. But the features and designs are not the same.

Here is a comparison between these two nailers:

Gun loading

The main difference between these two nailers is the loading mechanism. As the coil nailer has a drum like a canister where the nails are loaded into a coil. It’s like a machine gun bullet loop.

Hitachi NV45AB2 Coil Roofing Nailer

On the other hand, in stick nailer, the loading mechanism is a bit different than coil framing nailer. In stick nailer, the nails are loaded in a long magazine and they come into a strip.

Learn about Flooring vs Roofing Nailer.

Learn About Siding vs Roofing Nailer Here

Capacity

Another main difference between coil and stick framing nailer is their nail holding capacity and this makes the basic difference between these two nailers. A coil framing nailer holds up to 300 nails in a canister which makes easy for the builders to do the roofing job faster.

On the other hand, a stick framing nailer holds up to 30 nails in one magazine which makes builders reload the magazine again and again.

Area of uses

Both types of nailers are used for framing structure. As coil nailer can hold more nails than other nailers so that it is used for roofing most of the time.

For roofing, because reloading the nailer is pretty time consuming and hectic, a builder has to climb up and down from the roof to reload the nailer so it will be easy if the nailer is loaded more nails at a time.

But for flooring, you need to use a different type of nail gun.

Stick framing nailer holds fewer nails at a time and lightweight so that this nailer can be used in any sector such as building a fence, structuring room or constructing a house frame.

NuMax SF2190 21-Degree Framing Nailer

It also has an angle which gives it to work with the corner more efficiently rather than coil framing nailer.

Weight

As there is an addition in the coil nailer to hold the nails so that it is much heavier than stick framing nailer. A coil framing nailer weights up to 17 pounds.

On the other hand, a stick framing nailer weights around 9 pounds which makes builders comfortable to work with a stick framing nailer.

Conclusion

Both coil and stick framing nailer are used in heavy-duty house building tasks but still, their designs, features, and size make a huge difference between them.

As coil framing nailer holds more nails than a stick nailer so that its mainly used in roofing job on the other hand as stick framing nailer has an angle and get the corner so it’s mainly used in the fencing and other framing jobs.

Related Posts:

Jerry Jhonson
 

Jerry Johnson is a tech & tool geek who loves to talk, discuss and review different tools used for our day to day life. All the tools reviews and guides described in this site are completely from his personal experience and own observations.